Help very much appreciated. There’s room for an expansion to add more types of vassals/tribute/treaties that might be better. SnooStories8859. All that said, Protectorates are by far the best subject type to stock up on, for that sweet +0. If we had an overlord government in real life, the overlord could give out specific tasks to its vassals. think negotiating vassal terms should be a littlebit cheaper in terms of influence. The thing is in my game me and my 3 vassals far outwieghed the might of the country i entered into a tribute agreement. Nope. Two ways to get a vassal. Each vassal automatically gets 10% of every other vassal's trade. ; About Stellaris Wiki; Mobile view So 15% basic tribute gives about -500 acceptance. The +15% resources is a further bonus to your political power at level 5, and in the meantime it means you can get slightly more from vassals in taxes. You will start in a consumer goods deficit. You can only subjugate by force if the empire is weaker than you since overlord. I currently share a trade league with 6 other empires, and all of them have to vote with me. • 7 yr. Austensibly this could be enough to buffer for the ”tribute canceled” penalty, putting them in reach for accepting client status in short order. I RP that the overlords install some of their leaders onto their vassal's planets to look over. vassal liberation/secret fealty wars are radically stacked in favor of the overlord. The rights and obligations. When you click the "Propose Subjugation" it'll open up your contract window you first need to change the vassal type through the drop down menu. If you don't have the influence to fully claim a large empire, then vassalize -> Integrate will let you absorb them afters some time. ago. Mr. The "Vassalize" War Goal and You: A Lesson learned the strange way. Scholarium: Bonus to research, penalty to fleep can and upkeep. Depending on your tradition choices, you may want one over the other I suppose. Once the request appears invite them to make a federation, after it's creation go to the vassal request and accept it. By: lpslucasps. Their ships also have twenty percent more Hull points, move twenty percent faster, regenerate Hull and Armor. You can do both. GazOCee. Going in I knew I would not be able to complete the full vassalize requirements (as you have to just about conquer them both), so intended to stop at a good status quo point to create a new vassal for me, leaving the shell of the one of former empires with only a. or a larger sector as a Scholarium, but that's a particular kind of vassal at a particular point in the game, which I think doesn't apply to the OP. Correction: Only voluntary protectorates give you influence. So if a xenophile has a xenophobe vassal, he can grant his xenophobe vassal "cleanse planet" wargoals. Edit: To correct myself: You can create a vassal of your own species, but only your homeworld. Not having a big directly controlled territory is also good for tradition costs. Inward Perfection -> Crisis empires, for example, need the Imposed Inclusion CB to vassalize as under normal circumstances they can only demand tribute, and if refused they can't go to war to force tribute. ”. Tributaries themselves are kinda meh and supposedly pretty bugged in 1. tribute, or vassalization with any nations, but war does not limit diplomacy, and recently conquered modifier lasts 100 years with different phases from the instant guaranteed revolt if your army leaves with -1000% happiness. All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos Workshop News Guides Reviews. Without it all vassals are good for are buffer states. Tribute pays from total, not net, income, so when you raise the tribute demand at 75%, you're literally demanding 75% of all income. No chance or choice for new at all. And because of a distraction by a event i proposed a change that would be refused. Anyways, about the main question -- I generally approach the federation/vassals choice in terms of a long term diplomatic plan. You could conceivably stack vassal influence buildings to drain the subject of influence until it loses, assuming there's no cooldown on proposing changes, but there is almost certainly better uses for the influence (including flat-out creating, conquering, and then releasing a vassal with perfect alignment, better economy techs/traditions, and. 7. Federation members keep difficulty bonuses. vassalization acceptance REALLY needs a rework. Also members are said to have more independance than vassals do. The broken part is that you can get any contract, even one with a 75% tax on everything. If you vassalize an empire with vassal, the vassal should keep it’s vassal. Tribute is better for more powerful empires. Other than that, as a vassal or tributary you can't freely stop being a vassal. This mod-collection is created to make playing with Vassals, Tributaries, Protectorates and Subsidiaries. The rights and obligations. I just think that is a bit expensive. 15 research production rate. Vassalization request towards a Machine Intelligence empire. The bordergore can get horrendous when you're trying to. As ever, your civilization can rise from a post-apocalyptic past, departing to the stars. This mod expands how vassals work. Authors description: Exalted Domination – Vassals And Tributaries. • 7 yr. Sectors allow you to assign Governors, which give bonuses to all planets in the sector. Forced submission: You automatically get a subjugation Casus Beli on any empire that is overall "inferior" to you in fleet, tech, and economic power. Vassals can lead to scenario where your ships have to go through friend space to reach your other owned sectors. I'm flabbergasted that the expansion shipped with no safeguard for this kind of situation; a situation that can't be that uncommon. Nope, and it's awful. submit or rebel), you're completely at the whim of what your vassal deems acceptable which is reflected in the acceptance value. Then you could sit on top. Almost all vassals from military conquest start at -100 loyalty anyways, so the -4 does nothing, they are already on max disloyalty. For a regular empire, it can happen the other way too -- you start with a Tributary, then it auto-switches to a Protectorate, and then later it auto-switches to a Vassal -- losing your Tributary resource contract entirely, you have to spend Influence to re-negotiate, and whatever you negotiate is thrown away if it swaps into Protectorate again. DeanTheDull • Necrophage • 1 yr. We slowly, methodically, build up our infrastructure. Все. 14. That doesn't prevent the new vassal from starting with it on. Much like Paradox’s own Crusader Kings 3. The issue here (judging from the stream) - we are not able to negotiate with the vassal to change their inner policies. It is the same cost for another of my subjects which is 4 times the size. Dozens of reviews and discussions complaining that vassals are not slaves. Either conquer or purge all others you meet. All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos Workshop News Guides Reviews. #3. A vassal state is a nation that is independent from another, but gives full military support to its dominant nation when requested. As a result, many empires simply do not need a large number of planets anymore, and by extension do not need. • 7 yr. 10. You can attack realistically attack void dwellers and ringworlders early in the game. ecnel •. After that, it’s up to you to make the choice! How Do Tributaries Work? A vassal actually gets bonuses for serving under you in exchange for being subject to your diplomatic choices, i. I'd only use liberation if you plan as retaining them as a vassal, although do note that empires will. . Today, more common terms are puppet state, protectorate, client state, associated state or satellite state. Vassal cost 60 (NO MATTER THE SIZE!) while 3 planets cost roughly 90 warscore. The option is there to turn the tributary into a vassal, but I have a negative score (-41) to actually do this. Since you can do contract negotiations, there shouldn't be any difference right because you can just set all the categories to the same setting right? Stellaris Real-time strategy Strategy video game Gaming. The result is a very friendly new recruit for your Trade League who is probably also a. In general, halving the empire size per researcher doubles the limit on how quickly you can research. A country can become a vassal either through diplomatic or military means, and may eventually be annexed peacefully ("diplo-annexed") to the ruling kingdom. I definitely agree but the vassal system is very underdeveloped in stellaris (and basically irrelevant, without mods as the vassals get no bonuses). And that's it. The benefits of a tributary vs a standard vassal in 3. '. With the rework that means you can specialize your vassals Disregard the Diplomacy tradition at first, instead focus on filling out Supremacy. vassals can be integrated into your empire so you can eat them without claims or war. Presumably, both should cancel each other out. Probably the easiest way to get a good, solid vassal, though, is by regular conquest. they're very flexible, but require some time to set up. To do this method, whoever you’re trying to make your Vassal must be at peace. Involuntary protectorates (those forced on by war, or those forced on uplifted species) will not give you +1 influence. That's interesting, I didn't know (or I guess notice) that protectorates can colonize but vassals can't. Snuff out as much of the competition as you can in the early years before the galactic community forms and claim your place as a galactic superpower. In any case, you automatically have defensive pacts with vassals/protectorates, and defensive pacts drain influence. Garrison for +2 loyalty/month. The second vassal everyone will want is the Scholarium, who provides a significant bonus to research potential and valuable science tribute. See screenshots for new tradition effects. I'd only use liberation if you plan as retaining them as a vassal, although do note that empires will. Tag switch using console, release vassal, switch back. All subject types now grant a small degree of influence, which can be put. So right now I'm playing a hivemind game, and there is this absolutely pathetic nation which I REALLY want to cede so I can eat em, but the problem is they don't use the same planet type as I do (10% habitability). So, if you have enough influence, you can brute force the change. 1. 1. manniepants Jun 18, 2022 @ 6:44pm. Age of Wonders 4 Empire of Sin Cities: Skylines 2 Crusader Kings 3 Europa Universalis 4 Hearts of Iron 4 Hunter: The Reckoning. Tributaries aren't very useful. Honestly, Stellaris is another game than it was at release and I agree the war system still sucks, but the earlier one was just complete shambles. I have been thinking about this for a while and I think vassalisation is overpowered. Shun diplomacy. Envoys are minor leaders that can be assigned to perform various diplomatic tasks. ago. That said, yes as they currently stand Vassals are incredibly powerful. Thread starter Less2; Start date Mar 19, 2023;. I typically vassalize Fallen Empire core worlds and. You can't change it because they're not a vassal. You can only subjugate by force if the empire is weaker than you since. You can declare war of independence then use the console to switch to overload and accept the independence. 2. The second is increasing the reward you get from having vassals. The problem is that vassals don't get AI difficulty bonuses, meaning the moment you vassalize an empire on higher difficulties it becomes much, much weaker. It might be different in 2. Each vassal type has certain limits on what you can demmand of them. I tend to set up sectors before releasing, eg optimise their resources and structures etc. Afaik there's really no way to speed this up. There should be a tab that says something like:"Demand tribute" or "Demand subjugation". In some cases, the obligation included paying tribute, but a state which does so is better described as a tributary state. Another thing is that the empire they border is someone I am trying to keep as an ally (right now we have a non-aggression. The values are percentages of the production of the subject - in the proposal below, our vassal is offering 15% of their basic resource production as tribute, but is receiving a research subsidy. Push his face in the dirt This costs you zero influence, and resets the vassal to such an unpalatable deal that he'll eagerly accept whatever changes you like after the 5 year cool down. It can even get to the point where taking all of their planets and annihilating their fleets isn't enough; eventually they will get 100. Select the target from the “Empires” tab, select “Communicate,” and then select “Declare War. In terms of game metrics, this will be a monthly 5 influence cost per population and a 50-influence cost per planet. My empire is warmonger, it seems unfitting to "negotiate" with the target, is there a way to subjugate them in war? Before you used to be able to "demand vassalization" or "demand tribute" and then go to war if they refused but I don't see those options anymore. Stellaris desperately needs a threaten mechanic. Tributaries are mostly free, they can expand and do diplomacy but need to pay you a quarter of their income. its entirely onesided and hurts overlord more. its entirely onesided and hurts overlord more. If you vassalize them you can turn them into a boost for your science or navy? Depends what you need more of I guess. The "Vassalize" War Goal and You: A Lesson learned the strange way. 5 per stationed army). • 2 yr. They'll like you a lot after the war so it will really come down to size/power difference between your empire and theirs. until they declare war on you. by rite the vassal is not someone you would be ordering around its someone your meant to be guiding as an ally IE you help them so they help you. You don't need the imperial government for the feudal society civic either. Vanilla vassals do almost nothing. Toggle signature. Stellaris. Subscribe to downloadVassals and Tributaries - Exalted Domination [3. Presumably overlord takes a research tribute and gives them protection somehow. Frustrating Vassal mechanics - Even with maximum loyalty, the most favourable terms possible and overwhelming fleet power compared to them: It's impossible to contract even the smallest payment or to specialise their vassal type. And, if they don't have the influence they are forced to accept. It is far easier and faster than trying to conquer individual planets. 17. You might expect a cold war or even hot war situation once the galaxy is divided in 2-3 power blocks, but stellaris just doesnt seem to favor that. Gains bonuses by admiring its collection. a tributary pays you tribute. A vassal is directly controlled by an empire, whereas a subject pays tribute. While the new vassal contracts are a huge improvement over the old system, I feel that most AI empires are just jumping into a vassal-overlord contract too easily, while in my opinion federations should fill the role of defending mutual interests when empires aren't too weak to resist a powerful neighbor or when the powerful empire is not. Scion is like picking an adult who's willing to demolish every child on the other team as if it would prove something. Research costs are +150% for planets and 209% for pops. ago. 12th May 2022. If I can make tributaries -> vassals and then diploannex them at a later date, I'm peachy. You only get taxes from sectors, and you. No empire in the game, AI or player, is actually set up so that they run off of 25% of all basic resources flows so that 75% goes into the bank- that's incredibly inefficient over-production for a non-tributary. Go to Stellaris r/Stellaris. After a protectorate becomes a vassal, you must wait 10 years in order to annex them (the game says 3600 days) and THEN you get control of their planets and fleets. Vassalizing empires is definitely my favorite way to win (tied with Rogue Servitors). When should you create vassals? I have hundreds of hours in the game, but I've yet to ever release a vassal from my own territory. Content is available under Attribution-ShareAlike 3. It's a detailed breakdown of which factors speak for and against accepting the demand. r/Stellaris. war, peace, etc. 3. It's a detailed breakdown of which factors speak for and against accepting the demand. willldebeast • 4 yr. Report. A big part of vassals in the 20th century (both American and soviet during the cold War and even today for Russia, America, and even the gulf states) is having the vassal's cooperation in the. Releasing a vassal with a fraction of the pops lets them grow much, much faster. You can check the modifiers by hovering over the red x (or the green checkmark) next to the demand vassalization text. So 15% basic subsidy gives about +50 acceptance. Vassals are separate empires who fight in your wars for you, while sectors are parts of your empire that build things for you. You can exclude vassals from federations if they tank federation cohesion, but they also donate enboys so it is ok even with different ethos. I RP that the overlords install some of their leaders onto their vassal's planets to look over. Age of Wonders 4 Empire of Sin Cities: Skylines 2 Crusader Kings 3 Europa Universalis 4 Hearts of Iron 4 Hunter: The Reckoning Imperator: Rome Prison Architect Stellaris Surviving Mars Surviving the Aftermath Vampire: The Masquerade Victoria 3. Go to Stellaris r/Stellaris. Yeah. CryptoCould've sworn they got rid of the whole "defensive pacts in alliances and federations" thing with 1. 14. The only way to do this is to cheese it. 2. It reminds me of total war three kingdoms. 45% basic tribute gives about -500 acceptance. 1 This mod expands how vassals work. In game terms, I prefer vassals of nations I want to make more stable so they can support my empire-either via integration or by providing a safe and loyal ally. Our empires consider each other enemies. If you can just use tribute to get your Minerals/Energy/Food, you can devote your planets primarily towards industry and you need very few planets for that. 3. Description: This mod aims to improve the Domination tradition so that it is an appealing option at any stage of the game and also adds several new vassal and tributary types that are more evocative and useful to an overlord. Next to the “Demand Vassalization” button will either be a green tick or a red cross. The overlord can't curtail their expansion, doesn't interfere in any of their wars (and vice versa), the tributary simply feeds them resources. At 100 loyalty, they will gain 10 XP per month. which likely won't happen unless you declare war on them with the Demand of vassalization. • 1 yr. Unsourced material may be challenged and removed. In Stellaris Terms a Federation is like a Alliance with benefits. Just from a narrative point of view, you're supposedly helping your subjects against their rebels, and for you to "help" your subjects against their rebellion by taking all of the rebel lands for yourself (somehow magically getting free claims on these systems in. I hope this is fixed because the potential for these systems is great! Conquering directly just gives you the planets and populations directly, and will generally be strongest. Sometimes, vassals are used to help manage large empires, though often suboptimally. It is far easier and faster than trying to conquer individual planets. I have the Domination tradition maxed out, I demand either of it diplomatically, they refuse, but then I don't get the corresponding war goals when I want to declare war to force my will onto them. Can't demand tribute/vassalization Hi, so I think I know the technical procedure to get the demand vassalage/tribute war goals. I recently got into this game, and in my current game I’m playing as a very militaristic empire. You are too far ahead with your Research. On higher difficulty settings the Federation is absolutely the way to go if you want this style of gameplay. That doesn't prevent the new vassal from starting with it on. It might be more useful if the ai wasn't worthless outside of spinning off a vassal sector as a feudal empire to expand on their own and get around the influence bottleneck it might have some very niche uses. ^ these is already in the game. Vassal states were common among the empires of the Near East, dating back to the era of the Egyptian, Hittite and Mitanni conflict, as well as ancient China. if you want their territory you vassalize, if you want their energy credits and very much dont want to annex them you go tributary. -Tributaries donate income to you, they will not follow you into a war, they can engage in diplomacy and claim systems. Rord64 Mar 18, 2018 @ 6:06am. It makes changes to what they provide to their overlord. So as a weaker empire, you rather want to be inside a hedgemony than be a vassal. You can make your vassals tribute pops, unity, alloys, CGs, strategic resources, naval cap, any number of things really. These are broken into Basic, Advanced, or Strategic resource groups, and Research. Loyalty with Vassals is not realy an issue if you conquer a part of the galaxy, put your own species there and then release the vassal peacefully with your own dominant species. vassals are better than having tributaries or trying to conquer one planet at a time because they can be integrated into you country for some cost in influence and will cost far less to demand than the sum of all of their planets added together. ago. If you are a megacorp with Franchising. Oscot King of Space Portugal. The way I see it, you have 4 options: As you said, make your own federation & collect vassals. ago. 5. Having industrial tribute is good for that as well. 2. Similarly, in Stellaris, if your three vassals could easily defeat you in a war, you should. ”. Whereas a tributary. Abiliti to switch vassals type tribute-vassal and other way around. These are broken into Basic, Advanced, or Strategic resource groups, and Research. (So in case as humans you move your capital to alpha centauri and. If the game is using "subject" to specifically mean "tributary" in only this case, that deviates greatly from the general use of "subject. Two of the most popular subject empire types are tributary and vassal. One correction here. This facilitates faster pop growth than having all the pops integrated into one empire. Tributaries, unlike vassals, are semi-independent - they pay tribute to their overlord, but are otherwise left alone. Supposedly there was a time when vassal play was overpowered, but the current meta greatly favors one big empire so there's really no reason to do it. The player can then transfer additional systems to their vassal through the Trade option "Transfer System" if they so choose. 3] This mod aims to improve the Domination tradition so that it is an appealing option at any stage of the game and also adds several new vassal and tributary types that are more evocative and useful to an overlord. The names are kind of misleading and the exact opposite honestly, and could use a bit of a rework. Having an Alliance with somebody who has no "say-so" is just extra stats for the sake of it. Third is that people will want a Bulwark, but probabably as a 1-planet minor vassal, in order to get significant starbase discounts (20%) that will also apply to planetary rings. Being a vassal in CK3 can be weaponized, many a player liege has found out the hard way just how vulnerable they can be to a player vassal with a shiny loyalty hook on them. 0 unless otherwise noted. No empire in the game, AI or player, is actually set up so that they run off of 25% of all basic resources flows so that 75% goes into the bank- that's incredibly inefficient over-production for a non-tributary. Eathlome. e. Use the federation to become stronger than the other members and make them vassals peacefully with restricted voting, then take control of the galactic. ago. Go to Stellaris r/Stellaris. -must be neighbor. This unlocks the Supremacist diplomatic stance, which doubles the diplo weight you get from your navy. This would allow feudal societies to expand naturally. Only by declaring war can you change it. Form the federation with someone else. Yeah it's way too easy on lower/scaling difficulties to rush a fleet and mostly peacefully vassalize the entire galaxy before midgame. Plan to have an integration contract later on, and you can effectively 'pop farm' your vassals in the mid/late game when natural growth slows to a crawl. Tributary. #3. If the vassal does not allow it pops to migrate- you can not affect it. . Description. If the total number is positive, you'll see a green checkmark and they'll accept the demand, otherwise they. It's also a lower war score cost. Everyone becomes a vassal despite being super powerful themselves, at least in stellaris you don’t get vassalized but in 3k you get tricked by the wording and get vassalized against your will. The way it works is first, you need ability off the unity tree, which. . Since 3. If Overlords could micro manage the empire types of their vassals then it would defeat half the reasons why the changes were made in the first place. Just colonize some crappy planet that is otherwise useless to you because of poor habitability in a system that isn't connected to the rest of your empire and release that single system as a vassal. Ability to tax vassals 5% of their energy at the cost of a negative modifier, any more would bring them too close to subsidiaries. So either this shouldn't matter to determine the vassalization acceptance OR it thould matter but can become positive with good relations. The requirements for vassals and tributaries are sick. From there, click on the Create Vassals. Plus they'll get to your technological level so that you get the scientist relay bonus if make them. Like Vassal 1 focuses all its invention on making a laser which can heat. You should try, I said 10 from the top of my head but as they grew (slowly, but they did) I got some 70 energy and 30 minerals before makng them protectorates. A vassal country is a country, a client state, that is subject to the rule of a foreign country. Find it a bit strange that vassals can’t have vassals. In ancient times tribute was essentially used as a method for keeping your potential enemies from getting “too strong”, because a smaller state paying tribute will, in theory, never grow larger than the state it’s. If I can make tributaries -> vassals and then diploannex them at a later date, I'm peachy. So a vassal currently at +100 loyalty suffers a -2 loyalty per month penalty, while those at -100 loyalty will get +2 loyalty per month. Stellaris. One was able to win since the defence forces never got healed from previous battles and they got wiped out by my defence fleet in the area and colonised with full fury again. There is a CB called "Leave Hegemony" which allows you to leave the federation by winning the war. If its set to benevolent we shouldn't be able to force anything on the vassal because we care about them and want them to prosper. 4. CalebS92. As far as I can tell, the only benefit you get from having vassals are: - You keep your Empire Sprawl down, keeping your research cheap so you can get up the tech tree faster. ago. The biggest bonus to having a vassal or tributary is the buffer zone so why not make them pay. I also claimed some of these systems after cleaning all of. ago. Never vassalize a human player. An empire can become a subject willingly via diplomacy, the acceptance dependent on a number of. You can declare a special war to get rid of the criminal offices though, so if you're confident that you can scrape through that with at least. Because you start out further away from the overlord than the others, the megacorp can pretty much always reach the overlord before you do. ago. ago. The vassal doesn’t add to your sprawl, keeps their remaining civilian and military ships, and if you play it right continues to develop and donate even more to your empire. Envoys can be assigned to the following. A vassal cannot colonize new planets. ago. Stellaris. vassal turns into a protectorate but without the bonus or influence gain and resets your agreement. Play on Commodore difficulty or higher, since then your vassals will get +5 stability on every colony per level of increased difficulty, and they should never go into shortages due to production bonuses from the difficulty setting. I think you need to have unrestricted wars policy to use it though. They cannot claim systems or engage in diplomacy. So 15% basic subsidy gives about +50 acceptance. Not having a big directly controlled territory is also good for tradition costs. Closed borders and vassal. Medium and larger they add a Spiritualist and finally on Large and larger there is a Megacorp. Now, lets compare it to how far we are with fusion and what there is to know and what problems there are to solve. Step 2: Trade any remaining planets to this vassal at no cost. Heck if they like you enough they may even be amicable to becoming a tributary. They're a tributary. I am playing a tall game as an extreme pacifist empire. Having a protectorate gives . Vassal if you plan on integrating him later, otherwise Tributary. You will start in a consumer goods deficit. Stellaris Dev Diary #312 - 3. I'd say it depends on your ethics, and thus options. usually protectorates never become vassals, since they need 50% of your tech and you can usually out-tech them. I mean, from a min-maxing game-as-chess point of view being awarded these territories is great, obviously. Ideology wargoal and after winning and their government and ethics shift you might be able to convince them to be your vassal or protectorate if they're small enough of an empire. It also has some special subject interactions that can be pretty useful in some cases. Alneowyld. "They may also swear Secret Fealty to one of your rivals in hopes that they’ll be able to follow them in an Allegiance War. So unless you play on ensign difficulty the answer is yes. g.